Labeling affects recyclability of your aluminum beer cans

Aluminum is an infinitely recyclable material, with over 75% of all the aluminum ever produced still in use today. And yet craft brewers often feel they have no choice but to contaminate aluminum beverage cans with plastic labels or shrink sleeves. Here, Rob Day, CEO at Tonejet looks at beverage can decoration, the damage caused by the use of plastic labels and sleeves on cans and why alternative digital technologies are the sustainable solution.

Did you know?

• Used aluminum drink cans can be recycled and back on supermarket shelves as new drink cans in as little as 60 days.
• Recycling aluminum takes 95% less energy than producing it from its raw materials.

The low-weight, shelf-presence and freshness benefits of the aluminum can mean that it has fast become the container of choice for beverage brands. This is especially true in the booming craft beverage market, which now extends beyond beer to hard seltzer, water and cocktails. Aluminum is also one of the most sustainable packaging materials, being infinitely recyclable: the reclamation and smelting process does not alter its properties (as it can with other materials) and it can be re-used again and again.

With the increased popularity of craft beverages comes an increased need to stand out to the consumer, leaving many smaller artisan producers looking for affordable short run decoration methods. This, more often than not, results in aluminum cans being labeled or sleeved using plastic materials and adhesives. Plastic must be used as it will survive the can filling and washing process, but it has a detrimental effect on the recyclability of the can. PVC is still the most popular material for labels and shrink sleeves: its use creates additional steps in the recycling process and increases the number of cans which are rejected at the recycling center and end up in landfill.

The desire to be carbon-neutral and a growing awareness of sustainable digital packaging technology is driving the adoption of new direct decoration technologies for some, but the majority of craft beverage producers remain unaware that the use of plastic label materials compromises the sustainability of the otherwise 100% recyclable aluminum can. To wrap a material that can be indefinitely recycled in any kind of plastic seems illogical.

Organizations like The Aluminum Association are helping to drive awareness and recently produced a container design guide aimed at maximizing full circular recycling of aluminum. The guide explains that in the United States, an increased use of plastic labels and ring-pulls, shrink sleeves, adhesives and other unrecyclable components is diluting the value of aluminum, causing operational and compliance problems for recyclers and safety issues for workers.

As a result, authorities are beginning to legislate against the use of shrink sleeves and labels. In Quebec, for example, beverage cans must not carry labels or sleeves that represent more than 1% of the package total weight. Since Aluminum is so light, a label will typically add 10% to its weight, so cannot be used. A total ban on the use of plastic shrink sleeves on beverage cans is predicted later this year.

What to do instead? As we have seen in other packaging markets, digital innovations will revolutionize this industry. Mass-market beverage cans are offset-printed directly when the can is manufactured, but this analogue approach in uneconomical for shorter runs. It is now possible using inkjet technology to print directly onto the Aluminum can with no setup costs, making short runs possible. For craft brewers, this removes the recycling headaches associated with plastics, is lower in cost and provides a higher quality result than labeling or sleeving, indistinguishable from that of a traditionally printed can.

Direct-to-can digital decoration has moved from technology conference topic to commercial reality in the last two years and continues to grow. Both craft beverage producers and global brands should understand the opportunity afforded by digital packaging for beverage can decoration.

Two digital approaches are currently available: piezo drop-on-demand inkjet (using UV curing inks) and Tonejet, which deposits food safe pigments digitally before over-coating with standard beverage can varnishes. UV curing inkjet inks suffer emissions problems when burned off in the can recycling process, and should therefore be used with care.

At Tonejet we have tried to design a system which combines the best aspects of traditional can printing processes – low-cost materials which can be handled and recycled without damaging the environment, and which are tough enough to survive the supply chain – with the classic digital printing benefit of low cost short runs and lead times measured in days not months.