UPDATE September 2014: Spent grain is NOT going to be regulated by new animal feed rules, says FDA
Entrepreneurial, eco-conscious craft brewers across the country have found a side business of selling or just giving the spent grain from their production process to local farms to feed livestock. It’s a great practice, but one that might be more complicated soon.
Back in October 2013, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) proposed a rule to establish best practices for manufacturing animal feed. Under this definition, craft breweries would be labeled animal feed manufacturers and be regulated as such by the FDA. In fact, breweries are specifically called out within a subsection:
“For example, FDA understands that many breweries and distilleries sell spent grains, such as brewers dried grains and distillers dried grains, as animal food. Because those spent grains are not alcoholic beverages themselves, and they are not in a prepackaged form that prevents any direct human contact with the food, the Agency tentatively concludes that subpart C of this proposed rule would apply to them.”
Each facility would be required to prepare and implement a written food safety plan, which is essentially a long list of checks and balances and re-checks and re-balances. They are in the rule as follows:
Hazard analysis — This would identify and evaluate known or reasonably foreseeable hazards for each type of animal food manufactured, processed, packed or held at the facility.
Preventive controls — These are to provide assurances that hazards that reasonably likely to occur would be significantly minimized or prevented. These would address, for example, animal food processing, prevention of cross-contamination and sanitation affecting animal food safety. A recall plan would also be required.
Monitoring — Procedures that would provide assurance that preventive controls are consistently performed and records to document the monitoring.
Corrective actions — Facilities would be required to correct problems and minimize the likelihood of reoccurrence, evaluate the animal food for safety and prevent affected animal food from entering commerce.
Verification — Activities that ensure preventive controls are consistently implemented are effective. These might include records review of monitoring, correction actions or instrument calibration. Preventive controls would also be required to be validated to ensure they are effective in controlling the hazard. In addition, the food safety plan must be reassessed at least every three years.
Recordkeeping — Firms would be required to keep a written food safety plan, including hazard analysis. They would be required to keep records of preventive controls, monitoring, corrective actions and verification procedures.
There is a potential small business exception on the table that would exclude companies that fall within a $500,000 to $2.5 million sales window. Craft breweries should keep an eye on this, dig into the rule if they wish, and perhaps make a comment by the Feb. 26 deadline.
Do you give away or sell your spent grain, currently? Would new rules prevent you from doing so in the future?
RT @BrewersLaw: #Breweries & #distilleries may have to stop selling spent grains unless they comply with FDA rules. #grainlaw http://t.co/p…
#Breweries & #distilleries may have to stop selling spent grains unless they comply with FDA rules. #grainlaw http://t.co/pwzzYzesxd
RT @TweeterPete: It makes sense..if all other feed manufacturers have to do it, why shouldn’t breweries?…compost it at least! http://t.c…
Great comments from @beerinstitute on FDA’s proposed rule change for brewers spent grain. @CraftBrewingBiz #craftbeer http://t.co/O6YvShcwxX
.@blahblah_BEER leave it to the govt to eliminate a voluntary transaction beneficial to all sides. http://t.co/pzmjJtL1VA
FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed http://t.co/7BlN01L4k0
RT @blahblah_BEER: Breweries that give spent grain 2 farmers could be labeled animal feed manufacturers & regulated as such by the FDA. htt…
Breweries that give spent grain 2 farmers could be labeled animal feed manufacturers & regulated as such by the FDA. http://t.co/FtlYqc9Wew
RT @HughesBrews: Proposed FDA rule hopes to regulate brewers’ spent grain that is sold as animal feed. #craftbeer http://t.co/WihT8EqARG vi…
Proposed FDA rule hopes to regulate brewers’ spent grain that is sold as animal feed. #craftbeer http://t.co/WihT8EqARG via @craftbrewingbiz
RT @beerblog: Should craft brewers be labeled as animal feed manufacturers & regulated as such by FDA? @CraftBrewingBiz article. http://t.c…
RT @RiverCityRed: We give our spent grain to a pig farmer to supplement feed. We think better than garbage but new FDA regs may stop: http:…
Thanks Big Brother!… http://t.co/Iy36cXkUOs
Let’s make it more difficult, why don’t we?
FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed-Craft Brewing Business http://t.co/oa0vADhSnA
RT @TheOrtiz01: More possible government red tape for craft brewers. http://t.co/MfwwbwFA8g
More possible government red tape for craft brewers. http://t.co/MfwwbwFA8g
Annoying government interference or good food safety policy? Rules for brewer’s & distiller’s spent grains as feed http://t.co/2hyG4CQEzA
Interesting MT @RiverCityRed: We give spent grain to a pig farmer. Better than garbage. New FDA regs may stop that: http://t.co/dultFIKBLx
RT @RiverCityRed: We give our spent grain to a pig farmer to supplement feed. We think better than garbage but new FDA regs may stop: http:…
We give our spent grain to a pig farmer to supplement feed. We think better than garbage but new FDA regs may stop: http://t.co/YFCfxKlF1m
As if craft brewers didn’t alreay have enough red tape: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed http://t.co/WQDtTLvBtM #craftbeer
RT @beerblog: Should craft brewers be labeled as animal feed manufacturers & regulated as such by FDA? @CraftBrewingBiz article. http://t.c…
Should craft brewers be labeled as animal feed manufacturers & regulated as such by FDA? @CraftBrewingBiz article. http://t.co/6333yeba3D
FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed – @CraftBrewingBiz http://t.co/Sr4iZ1PYJR
Leave it to gov. to ruin perfect harmony btwn local producers: brewers & farmers http://t.co/w1KNkI3RvE
RT @BrewandCovered: Brewers have a side business selling/giving spent grain to local farms. It might be more complicated soon. http://t.co/…
RT @BrewandCovered: Brewers have a side business selling/giving spent grain to local farms. It might be more complicated soon. http://t.co/…
Brewers have a side business selling/giving spent grain to local farms. It might be more complicated soon. http://t.co/OM9jMTGRDK
Well this is about the dumbest thing ever! Whatever happened to the government encouraging going green? #craftbeer http://t.co/DlQnERajxK
This seems like tremendous governmental overreach for a practice that should be a “win-win” for everyone. Have… http://t.co/P0NEmdkDM2
RT @mouldsbeerblog: Brewers selling/giving spent grain to farmers may not be so easy in the future – via @CraftBrewingBiz http://t.co/T2l4S…
“@ChrisYMcCoy: Govt is stupid H/T @jengratz FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed EVEN GIVEN AWAY http://t.co/RBIMLpcZld”
Govt is stupid H/T @jengratz FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed EVEN GIVEN AWAY http://t.co/xfcCuSQh6e
It makes sense..if all other feed manufacturers have to do it, why shouldn’t breweries?…compost it at least! http://t.co/xfgNXsARQz
@CraftPittsburgh Kinda makes sense. In these parts though, it’s usually given and not sold. @petolo_el_loco @craftbrewingbiz
RT @mouldsbeerblog: Brewers selling/giving spent grain to farmers may not be so easy in the future – via @CraftBrewingBiz http://t.co/T2l4S…
RT @mouldsbeerblog: Brewers selling/giving spent grain to farmers may not be so easy in the future – via @CraftBrewingBiz http://t.co/T2l4S…
.@eastendbrewing. MT @petolo_el_loco: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed – http://t.co/oeYvxFAO3f via @craftbrewingbiz
RT @melloknows: Potential FDA rules on brewery spent grain may lead to a lot less happy cows in the future: http://t.co/1glxxKgMeT
FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed – Craft Brewing Business http://t.co/aCKJlh7Ceo via @craftbrewingbiz
@Dukester @CraftBrewingBiz I wasn’t aware it was “sold”; I thought it was “I give it to you so I don’t have to pay for disposal”
Potential FDA rules on brewery spent grain may lead to a lot less happy cows in the future: http://t.co/1glxxKgMeT
RT @Dukester: Proposed FDA rule would regulate spent grain sold as animal feed to farmers. http://t.co/LhxZ8fHn9x via @CraftBrewingBiz #cra…
Brewers selling spent grains might be impacted by proposed FDA rule – note poss. small business exemption though http://t.co/iwtowvh3C6
Proposed FDA rule would regulate spent grain sold as animal feed to farmers. http://t.co/LhxZ8fHn9x via @CraftBrewingBiz #craftbeer
FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed – Craft Brewing Business http://t.co/21EqKts30L
RT @Homebrewchef: Spent Grain: http://t.co/IRMzOOvLFI
RT @BSGPeter: New rules could be changing the game for breweries sending spent grain to cattle farmers. http://t.co/tXgDpDA2fE
RT @Homebrewchef: Spent Grain: http://t.co/IRMzOOvLFI
RT @Homebrewchef: Spent Grain: http://t.co/IRMzOOvLFI
Spent Grain: http://t.co/IRMzOOvLFI
No joke. Interested in the exemption too. RT @justjptweet: This is certainly some to keep an eye on: http://t.co/k12xomF1gh h/t @AleGrrl –
FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed http://t.co/VsDwRoymsJ
This is certainly some to keep an eye on: http://t.co/O5ejYA6JhS h/t @AleGrrl
Brewers selling/giving spent grain to farmers may not be so easy in the future – via @CraftBrewingBiz http://t.co/T2l4SJQOdc
Yo, beer people: True? RT @BSGPeter: New rules cd change game for breweries sending spent grain to cattle farmers. http://t.co/3I9xhSOiEp
RT @BSGPeter: New rules could be changing the game for breweries sending spent grain to cattle farmers. http://t.co/tXgDpDA2fE
RT @BSGPeter: New rules could be changing the game for breweries sending spent grain to cattle farmers. http://t.co/tXgDpDA2fE
New rules could be changing the game for breweries sending spent grain to cattle farmers. http://t.co/tXgDpDA2fE
Interesting…Do you sell or give away your spent grain to farmers?? http://t.co/ZtuF3RG3KB
What you say @ChadLensman http://t.co/074ZhwDnwp
RT @CraftBrewingBiz: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed: http://t.co/jPRsYlyoEo Will this affect your craft brewery?
@Weyerbacher @WeyerbacherHB http://t.co/gI5RGrmulE
RT @BSGJakeKeeler: Important news for breweries selling their spent grain as animal feed: http://t.co/3yBGZASx6a @CraftBrewingBiz
Important news for breweries selling their spent grain as animal feed: http://t.co/3yBGZASx6a @CraftBrewingBiz
RT @KalispellBrew: RT @CraftBrewingBiz: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed: http://t.co/8CJUVUgt7m Will this affect your c…
RT @KalispellBrew: RT @CraftBrewingBiz: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed: http://t.co/8CJUVUgt7m Will this affect your c…
RT @CraftBrewingBiz: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed: http://t.co/8CJUVUgt7m Will this affect your craft brewery?
RT @CraftBrewingBiz: FDA rule regulates spent grain sold as animal feed: http://t.co/jPRsYlyoEo Will this affect your craft brewery?